Thursday, 6 April 2017

Debating about Children in Art: Exploitation or Creativity?

Claire and I were debating about this subject. I was saying that the use of children in art is an exploitation while Claire was saying that it is creativity.

Although I did have some opinions about this subject, I did some research to learn more and to back up my arguments too. Meanwhile, I was also seeing how the use of children in art is considered as creativity too. I planned an introduction to the subject, and some points of rebuttal and to support my argument, and finally, a conclusion. Although this was my first time debating, I really enjoyed it. I noticed that I forgot to mention some points which I had prepared because I was not mentioning each point I had written but rather, responded to my opponent’s argument.  At one point she mentioned something and I did not really know how to elaborate on that, so instead of saying that I do not know how to respond, I responded her with a brief sentence and changed the subject on something else, obviously keeping the same topic. I think this was a good move as I took the opportunity to mention something else and not always elaborate on whatever she was saying. A mistake I did was that at first I did not mention the age group we were talking about even though I have researched about this. I did not mention it to keep the argument open and for myself to mention anything I want. However, when I got the opportunity to mention the age group and actually show that I researched about this too, I kind of blanked and did not know how to respond in the correct way. A flaw in my opponent’s argument then, is that she was asked a certain question and suddenly, she mentioned an example in my favour. When she was asked a different question, she could have given more reasons to back up her argument.

Both my opponent and I had some flaws in our arguments but I think we did quite well, especially for the first debate we participated in. 

No comments:

Post a Comment